Minds and Computers : An Introduction to the Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence
Download 1.05 Mb. Pdf ko'rish
|
document (2)
conditioned reflex arc.
Given these contemporaneous historical factors – the burgeoning of psychology, the flourishing of positivism and the development of Pavlov’s theory of reflex arcs – psychology was ripe for a paradigm shift. This was brought about by the American psychologist John Watson (1878–1958). 20 Watson was strongly in the grip of positivism and consequently rejected the legitimacy of introspection as a psychological tool, arguing that in order to be a positive science, psychology should concern itself only with observable behaviour. In doing so, he recon- ceptualised psychology – which had been seen as the science of human consciousness – as the science of human behaviour. Watson was interested in discovering the innate reflex arcs which governed human behaviour and investigating the circumstances under which reflex arcs could be conditioned in humans. To this end he engaged in experiments on babies and young children which would certainly never be approved by today’s ethics committees. To demonstrate the presence of innate reflex arcs in young babies, Watson showed that certain environmental conditions, such as sudden loud noise or a sudden loss of support (i.e. dropping them), would evoke fear behaviour in babies. Some might think these results less than remarkable. In investigating conditioned reflex arcs, Watson and his colleague Rosalie Rayner experimented on Albert B., an eleven-month-old infant. Albert would be presented with a white rat. When he reached out in curiosity to touch the animal, the experimenters would make a loud noise by striking a steel bar close to his head, thereby evoking fear behaviour in Albert. After only seven such presentations of the rat in conjunction with the loud noise – five of which were a week later than the first two – it was found that Albert would exhibit fear behav- iour on presentation of the rat alone. This conditioned response was subsequently found to be enduring and, further, transferable to similar stimuli. Albert would exhibit the same fear response on pre- sentation of a white rabbit and, to a lesser extent, on presentation of a dog, a fur coat or a Santa Claus mask. Following Watson, psychological behaviourism became dominant and held sway in psychology until roughly the late 1960s. During this period it became customary to carry out experimental work on rats where possible, beginning a tradition in psychology sometimes described – endearingly or pejoratively – as occupied with ‘rats and stats’. By far the most influential psychological behaviourist after Watson was another American, Burrhus Frederic (B. F.) Skinner (1904–90). Skinner was interested in determining the most e ffective means of conditioning reflex arcs. He invented a device, now called a ‘Skinner box’, in which rats could be placed. This box contained a lever which the rats were able to depress which could be set to deliver a food pellet when actuated. By varying the conditions under which the actuation 21 of the lever would yield a food pellet, Skinner was able to modify the behaviour of the rats accordingly. Unlike classical Pavlovian conditioning, this behavioural modifi- cation was contingent not just on the stimulus preceding the behav- iour (a ringing bell, a rat together with a loud noise) but also on the environmental stimulus following the behaviour. Skinner called this operant conditioning, and developed an associated theory of how best to e ffect operant conditioning by controlling the positive and negative reinforcement of certain behaviours. Skinner argued that such operant conditioning could be widely employed as a social engineering technique. He suggested that crim- inal behaviour was better treated with behavioural modification tech- niques rather than punished through incarceration, and he published a widely read novel, Walden Two, which outlined his utopian vision of a planned society governed by operant conditioning. As one might expect, these ideas were met with a mixture of commendation and condemnation. By the end of the 1960s, behaviourism in psychology had waned in popularity, in favour of the newly emerging cognitive psychology. There are good reasons for the loss of faith in the behaviourist con- ception of psychology. For one thing, it became clear that positivism is, simply put, a false doctrine. Modern science is frequently in the business of theorising about unobservable entities. Such treatment of unobservables does not make theoretical physics, for instance, ‘pseudoscientific’. More importantly, it became increasingly clear that many essential aspects of mentality are simply not directly connected to observable behaviour. The mechanisms which underpin memory, the capacity to draw inferences and the ability to comprehend language do not seem to be necessarily correlated with any particular kind of behaviour. As such, these cognitive functions are not amenable to investigation in the behaviourist tradition. While it is the case that each of the three traditions of psychology we have examined are now consigned to history, it is also the case that modern psychology preserves certain techniques from each of them. Where, however, each of these traditions were distinctly methodologically homogenous, modern psychology is markedly methodologically heterogeneous. There is still a place in psychology for psychophysical research, self-reporting is still a widely used tech- nique and there is still a role for the observation of behaviour. There is no longer any place though for the methodological monism which characterised these early periods of psychology. 22 3.5 PHILOSOPHICAL BEHAVIOURISM Psychological behaviourism, as we have seen, is a methodological view – a doctrine concerning the way in which one should go about doing psychology. Philosophical behaviourism, in contrast, is an Download 1.05 Mb. Do'stlaringiz bilan baham: |
Ma'lumotlar bazasi mualliflik huquqi bilan himoyalangan ©fayllar.org 2024
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling