It should be noted that a situation
may be Pareto optimal
without maximisation of social welfare. However, welfare
maximisation is attained only at a situation i.e. Pareto optimal.
The main limitation of Pareto criteria is that it cannot
evaluate a change that makes some people better off and others
worse off.
6.3 MARGINAL CONDITIONS FOR A PARETO
OPTIMAL RESOURCE ALLOCATION
Pareto optimality criteria refer to economic efficiency which
can be objectively measured. It is called Pareto criterion, after the
famous Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto.
Pareto has disagreed with the
neo-classical approach to
welfare. The neo-classical economist believed that the term social
welfare refers to the sum total of individual utilities which are
cardinally measurable. Pareto‘s
disagreement with the neo-
classical approach is because;
1) non acceptance of the cardinal measurement of utility.
2) Rejection of interpersonal composition of utility.
According to Pareto criterion,
any change that makes at
least one individual better off and none worse off is an improvement
of social welfare. Conversely a change that makes no one better
and at least one worse off is a decrease in social welfare.
This criterion can be alternatively stated as follows:
―An allocation is Pareto efficient
under a given set of
consumer taste, technology and resources. If it is no possible to
move to another allocation which could make some people better
off and nobody worse off.‖
Prof. Baumol has stated the same idea in the following words,
―Any change which harms no one and make some people better off
in their own estimation must be considered to be an improvement.‖
For the attainment of Pareto
optimal situation in an
economy, three marginal conditions are to be satisfied.
1) efficiency of distribution of commodities among the
consumers (efficiency in exchange).
2) efficiency of the allocation of the factors among firms
(efficiency of production).
3) efficiency in the allocation of
factors among commodities
(efficiency in product mix or composition of product)