Cross- cultural Communication This page intentionally left blank
Download 1.51 Mb. Pdf ko'rish
|
Cross Cultural Communication Theory and Practice PDFDrive (1)
- Bu sahifa navigatsiya:
- The limitations of cultural profiling
parties. Decide (D): the third step is to decide how to close the gap, that is, decid- ing whether to change or adjust your behaviour or ask the other person to do so by about 20 per cent, depending on the situation. Tomalin and Nicks recommend doing this by using the 80/20 principle to decide what 20 per cent change should be made to balance the relationship. Act (A): put what you have decided into action. Review (R): finally, and most importantly, review the outcome to check whether your approach has been successful. If not, try another approach. Remember that success is about doing more of what works and less of what does not. The principle behind the RADAR system is simple and reassuring. Huge changes are not necessary to achieve cultural compatibility. What are needed are small, incremental changes. Once those changes have been made, the other person in the adaptation process will often adapt more strongly to accommodate your willingness to change. This is a ‘rule of thumb’, validated by experience, but it is one of the simplest examples of how a framework can be applied to improve performance across cultures. The limitations of cultural profiling It is reasonable to question the scientific accuracy of the comparison as to whether the user’s perception of his or her style is correct and whether the expert analysis is more than the collected views of a number of informed observers. If it is not, in the absence of scientifically verifiable evidence, mapping does allow the user to identify possible differences in attitude, communication style and management style, and promotes reflection on how to harmonize the perceived difference. The understanding of culture is, as we have seen, ultimately an art, not a science. This kind of profiling is a way of indicating how to identify dif- ferences and how to adjust behaviour to optimize good relations with the other party, but it is not objectively verifiable. This is why it is a convenient tool for use in education and training and pre- departure briefing, but should not be used on its own as a definitive selection criterion. • • • • • 272 Cross-Cultural Communication The other problem with national cultural profiling is that the user’s style may not match the default national style. For example, in Japan, one of the key principles in negotiation is ‘nemawashi’ (preparation for collective negotiation) and ‘ringi-sho’ ( multiple- point formal sign-offs). The Japanese make decisions cautiously to ensure that everyone is fully supportive. Once this is achieved, negotiations can then move quickly forward. However, when the authors were analysing one company which was used to working with American organizations on a long- term basis, profiling revealed that the Japanese colleagues had adopted the practice of their American counter- Download 1.51 Mb. Do'stlaringiz bilan baham: |
Ma'lumotlar bazasi mualliflik huquqi bilan himoyalangan ©fayllar.org 2024
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling