A practicalities and experiences of being non-native english teachers in korea by sardor akramov. A student of
participants to an extent. This may be because they believed, as
Download 274.59 Kb. Pdf ko'rish
|
A Practicalities and experiences OF being NON 2-version
participants to an extent. This may be because they believed, as many of them stated, that their positions could not be completely escaped by any means; the title 'foreign teacher' in itself implies a perhaps inescapable Otherness. However, it could be argued that the particular Other that is the White foreign English teacher occupies a desirable position in the ethnic discourses of Korean society compared to other groups, much as it does in the discourses of other societies in Asia, such as Taiwan (Lan, 2011) and Japan (Appleby, 2013). As participants variously described it, they suffered only trifling discrimination, and/or were stereotyped in more positive, or less destructive ways than members of other minority groups, and enjoyed greater benefit of the doubt for their mistakes and predilections than they might have received had they been ethnically-Korean gyopos (Cho, 2012; Redmond, 2014), while possibly also being more free from social obligation than the members of the Korean ethnic majority. , participants variously fought against and embraced their Otherness, because this put them in a position where in their lives possessed a ‘special shape’ (Hennig, 2010) in two senses; they were special as foreigners from ‘richer countries’ (Nigel), and again as members of that group who had learned Korean and shown interest in Korean culture, contrary to expectations. Between the benefits of having acquired Korean and the privileges attached to being a White foreigner in Korea, all participants seemed to have found an agreeable space within the ‘pre-given power structure’ (Hennig, 2010) of Korean ethnic discourse. Conclusion The results of this research highlight a number of discourses relating to White foreign teachers of English in Korea, as language learners and long-term foreign residents, contributing to the body of research on discourses of ethnicity and immigration in Korea, and complementing existing research on foreign English teachers in Asia and theirdiscursive positioning as language educators (Appleby, 2013; Jeon, 2009). The discourses identified were as follows: foreign teachers generally cannot speak Korean; a teacher is worthy of respect for knowledge of Korean, because, by learning, they distinguish themselves from the perceived common behaviors of foreign teachers; even though a foreign teacher may learn Korean, an inextirpable (possibly ethnically determined) difference will continue to separate them from the Korean majority community as a whole; to be White is to occupy a position of relative privilege among ethnic groups in Korea. Further research on foreign teachers as Korean learners might be conducted to elaborate on these discourses. The sample size of this research being six individuals, all White and mostly male, a larger scale study on Korean-speaking foreign English teachers of varying ethnicities and with a greater proportion of women would likely reveal clarifying details about the hierarchy of ethnicities (and perhaps genders) in Korea, the privilege of White teachers, the potential social gains that can be made by learning Korean despite disadvantage resulting from ethnic positioning, and what may not be gained even by learning. Also, as many participants suggested that in general younger Koreans were more comfortable interacting with them in Korean despite theirethnicity and older Koreans were more likely to behave in an awkward manner, conducting this study again after some years may yield different results in terms of participants experiences and challenges, and these differences might reflect changing attitudes towards foreigners in Korean society over time.Knowledge of the foreign teacher-related discourses of Korea may be of use to those bearing responsibility for the training and support of foreign teachers, such as school principals and managers, public school English program coordinators, teacher educators, and recruiters, as this knowledge may serve to inform advice given to foreign teachers about the experiences they have, or are likely to have, living in Korea, and the benefits and implications of learning Korean. The accounts of experiences and perspective contained within this research should also be of interest to foreign teachers themselves, asthey may provide clarifying perspective on the reader’s own lived experiences, as they did for the author. Though a case may be made about the lack of benefits to learning foreign languages like Korean for L1 English speakers in some situations (Dustmann, 2000; Gordon, 2012), advantages of learning go beyond the practical and economic upsides of communicative ability and extend to the creation of our selves (Foucault, 1985) as culturally open-minded individuals, who may give and receive respect as a result of choosing to show interest, and thereby striving to bridge cultural, ethnic and community divides (Dustmann, 1996; Wenger, 1998). Learning Korean may not presently be sufficient in itself to entirely overcome perceptions of foreign English teachers, but participants in this study believed that it was a worthwhile undertaking for the positive. Some ability in the Korean language may potentially aid in the development of greater mutual understanding between foreign English teachers and Koreans, and contribute towards a modern Korean society ‘governed by mutual respect and freedom’ |
Ma'lumotlar bazasi mualliflik huquqi bilan himoyalangan ©fayllar.org 2024
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling